Rudy vs. Mitt: State Polling and the GOP Race

In the race for the GOP Presidential nomination there are two real frontrunners and three nipping at the formers’ heels.  It certainly appearst that either Rudy Giuliani or Mitt Romney are going to be the Republican nominee.  In the comments section of an article on Race42008, there is an interesting discussion going on about the respective strategies for winning the nomination of both Rudy and Mitt.

Rudy’s strategy is a national one.  He views February 5th as a national primary; a day in which truly significant states with large numbers of delegates are voting.  Ultimately Rudy’s plan is now to win Florida on January 29th to give him momentum and to ride the wave into a sweep of California, Texas, New Jersey, and New York (among others). 

On the other hand, Mitt’s strategy is of a more traditional nature.  He believes that victories in the early states are essential.   Victories in Iowa and New Hampshire will propel him to victories in Wyoming, Michigan, Nevada, and South Carolina.  He is further betting on this momentum to improve his standing nationally and to propel him to a win in Florida and, thus, a sweep in February.

So ultimately the race comes down to Florida. Or so it is being argued on Race42008, some Rudy supporters are even slyly implying that Giuliani has all but conceded Iowa and New Hampshire to Romney.  Ultimately, like any race, it is a question of momentum and movement.  

So considering all of this, I wondered what the polls are saying in regards to this momentum and movement.  Below are charts of polling in various states, what patterns do you see that are consistent throughout? (For larger charts visit

Rudy= Purple,  Mitt=Brown, McCain=Orange, Thompson=Blue, Huckabee=Green, Paul=Red


New Hampshire


South Carolina




What are the consistencies?  In every poll Romney is moving up and Rudy is either stale or going down.  Let’s look at Florida, as this is seems to be the key state, Rudy is taking a huge dive there and Romney is moving up fast.  Couple this is with Thompson’s dying campaign and momentum from likely victories in earlier states, and Mitt’s prospects for winning Florida sure look good.

Of course, a lot can happen in two months, however it sure seems to me that Romney has the smartest strategy to the nomination, despite Rudy’s seeming front runner status in national polls and from the MSM.  Trends tell a lot, and the trends don’t look good for Rudy, they look great for Mitt.



Filed under Conservative, Election 2008, Fred Thompson, John McCain, Mike Huckabee, Mitt Romney, Politics, Republicans, Ron Paul, Rudy Giuliani

8 responses to “Rudy vs. Mitt: State Polling and the GOP Race

  1. Pingback: Ron Paul - Presidential Candidate » Blog Archive » Rudy vs. Mitt: State Polling and the GOP Race

  2. Pingback: Rudy vs. Mitt: State Polling and the GOP Race | Political news - democrats republicans socialists greens liberals conservatives

  3. I like this. I like it a lot.

  4. veteransabroad

    So it looks like Ron Paul is not really in the running then. He is up to 5% with CNN and Rasmussen as of the 7th, two days after the “money bomb”. It will be interesting to see where his money takes him now that only he and Romney have the bucks to throw around on the Republican side.

    I just want to see the libertarians beat the religious types this time around and take the Republican Party leadership, regardless of who actually wins the nomination.

  5. IMHO, Rudy is conceding he is too liberal to win in Iowa, N.H, Nevada and S.C. He is banking on New York ex-pats in Florida and a left leaning California to propel him to victory.

    Only time will tell if he is right, but I continue to believe that Mitt Romney has got the right positions on issues that matter most to a broad spectrum of voters. Without the centrist voters, you can’t be elected President and Rudy is too far left to get their votes.

    ~~John Cronin~~

  6. A large group of Mitt supporters are organizing an event much like the one Ron Paul’s supporters had on November 5th. We are having it on the 7th of December and the website is

  7. Pingback: Top Posts «

  8. MJ

    The trend lines look very positive for Mitt Romney. By the way … Romney and Ron Paul aren’t the only one with “money to throw around”. Ron Paul still does not have the money Giuliani has. Sorry this isn’t a race between Ron Paul & Mitt Romney.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s